The Indiana Fever’s decisions in the 2025 WNBA Draft stirred disappointment and confusion among fans, as the team selected Makayla Timpson at No. 19, Bree Hall at No. 20, and Yvonne Ejim at No. 33. While these picks were clearly made with an eye toward improving the team’s defense and adding depth, a large portion of the Fever fanbase expected more offensively dynamic selections—especially with the opportunity to add players considered rising stars in scoring.
Many supporters had high hopes for Lucy Olsen, a standout talent who’s already earned comparisons to Caitlin Clark for her offensive firepower and court vision. Another fan-favorite option was sharpshooter Serena Sundell, whose scoring ability and perimeter shooting seemed like a perfect complement to Indiana’s existing core. Instead, the Fever went with players more known for their defensive work and potential versatility.
Social media erupted soon after the announcements, with one user calling the decision to pick Hall over Olsen “absurd,” citing Olsen’s superior scoring statistics and overall offensive polish. Others couldn’t believe that proven names like Deja Kelly and Sedona Prince weren’t taken at all during the draft, further amplifying the backlash against the front office.
Despite the criticism, Fever General Manager Amber Cox stood by the organization’s strategy. She highlighted the versatility and defensive upside the drafted players bring to an already competitive roster that includes stars like Caitlin Clark, DeWanna Bonner, and NaLyssa Smith. Still, with so much established talent already on the team, these rookies will have to fight hard to make an impact—and a place—on the final roster.
