The New York Mets are reportedly considering options to replace their star first baseman Pete Alonso, whose contract demands are expected to exceed $30 million annually. With uncertainty surrounding Alonso’s future, the team is exploring alternative solutions, including a potential trade for Baltimore Orioles’ first baseman Ryan Mountcastle.
Mountcastle, currently part of a platoon setup in Baltimore, could offer the Mets a reliable and cost-effective option at first base. Over his five-season MLB career, he has posted an OPS+ of 114, demonstrating consistent offensive potential. Unlike Alonso, Mountcastle would come with two more years of team control, making him an appealing target for a team looking to manage costs without sacrificing performance.
A hypothetical trade scenario has been proposed, where the Mets would acquire Mountcastle in exchange for pitcher José Buttó and prospect Dom Hamel. Buttó, who has shown promise in his limited appearances, and Hamel, a developing prospect, could entice the Orioles, especially given Mountcastle’s current role as part of a platoon rather than an everyday starter.
For the Mets, this move could provide long-term financial flexibility while still maintaining solid production at first base. By pivoting away from Alonso’s hefty contract demands, the team can potentially address other roster needs while adding a player like Mountcastle, who offers value and upside. Whether or not the Mets will proceed with such a trade remains to be seen, but the idea underscores the team’s willingness to explore creative solutions in shaping their roster for the future.
