The New York Yankees have signed former MVP Paul Goldschmidt to a one-year, $12.5 million deal to replace Anthony Rizzo as their first baseman. At 37 years old, concerns about Goldschmidt’s age and recent decline are valid, but his second-half performance in 2024 and underlying metrics offer reasons for optimism.
Goldschmidt’s 2024 season overall was underwhelming, with a .241/.302/.414 slash line. However, he rebounded in the second half, posting a solid .799 OPS. Despite his age, he remains a formidable hitter, ranking in the 92nd percentile for hard-hit rate. He also excelled against left-handed pitching last season, boasting an .839 OPS, which could make him an ideal candidate for a platoon role alongside 25-year-old Ben Rice.
The move makes sense financially and strategically, especially given Goldschmidt’s previous struggles came while playing for the struggling St. Louis Cardinals. In the Bronx, he joins a team with World Series aspirations, a setting that could reinvigorate his performance.
This signing likely signals more moves from the Yankees, particularly at second base. With Goldschmidt’s contract taking up just $12.5 million, the team appears poised to add a more established player at the position. It’s unlikely they’ll settle for internal options like DJ LeMahieu or Oswald Peraza as Opening Day starters.
Goldschmidt’s proven track record and strong finish to 2024 suggest he could still contribute significantly, especially in a more competitive environment. At this price, the gamble seems well worth it for a Yankees team looking to contend.
