The Yankees of 2025 face a future that is anything but uncertain or bleak. With strategic adjustments made possible by roster changes and unique circumstances, the team remains well-positioned among MLB’s elite franchises.
Their projected starting rotation boasts impressive depth and talent: Gerrit Cole, Max Fried, Carlos Rodon, Clarke Schmidt, and Luis Gil, with Marcus Stroman available for spot starts. Each of these pitchers could easily claim the role of opening day starter for teams outside the big-market spotlight.
While potential bullpen issues exist, this is a challenge faced by every MLB team, from the high-spending New York Mets under Steve Cohen to the rebuilding Oakland A’s. However, the Yankees have strengthened their bullpen with the addition of closer Devin Williams, eliminating any questions about who will anchor the late innings. Williams’ arrival also helps the team move on from the “bad vibes” surrounding Nestor Cortes. Despite Cortes’ unique pitching style and popularity, his departure feels akin to the Phillies moving on from Mitch Williams in the 1990s—a necessary change to repair wounds from tough losses.
The acquisitions of Fried and Williams significantly bolster the Yankees’ already formidable pitching staff. With these upgrades in mind, the batting order is poised to make the 2025 Yankees a stronger team compared to their 2024 AL Championship squad, which, despite its success, had visible flaws.
Offensively, the loss of Juan Soto will likely result in fewer home runs than last year’s league-leading 237. However, the lineup remains potent enough to stay competitive. The Yankees’ ability to adapt and refine their roster demonstrates their commitment to maintaining their place among MLB’s most dominant teams, setting high expectations for the 2025 season.
